Header graphic for print
Patent Practice Professional Liability Reporter Your Pacific Northwest Law Firm

Category Archives: Jury Instructions

Subscribe to Jury Instructions RSS Feed

Jury Notes and Special Verdicts in Patent Cases: A Case Study in Jury Comprehension

Posted in Jury Instructions, Patent Litigation, Patent Pleadings

It is commonplace to bemoan the lack of juror comprehension in patent cases and to describe jury deliberations as a “black box” resisting analysis. The Federal Circuit favors the use of special jury verdicts to alleviate such criticisms. Special verdicts can focus jury attention on the facts that may or may not support key patent findings… Continue Reading

Tracking Down the Elusive Obviousness Special Verdict Form

Posted in Jury Instructions, Patent Litigation

Judges and legal commentators have long cautioned patent practitioners about the pitfalls of “obviousness” jury determinations that pose only the ultimate question: Has defendant proven by clear and convincing evidence [or that it is highly probable] that Claim X of the ’123 Patent is obvious? Yes ____ No ____. Whether the answer is yes or… Continue Reading